Reflections on the Black Dahlia
Before starting my review of the films Hollywoodland and The Black Dahlia,
(see the Classic flms blog) I did some research and in particular on the infamous
brutal murder of Elizabeth Short who became known to the public as the Black
Dahlia. Much to my surprise, the Black Dahlia has turned into a regular cottage
industry. There were more than 20 websites devoted to the gruesome
1947 murder. There was a wealth of informative material, but I suppose which
is probably true with any events that are no longer current news, much of
the information included variations in the facts.
For example Elizabeth Short was listed as 5' 5" tall by some sources and 5' 6"
by others. There were all kinds of evaluations of what kind of a person she was,
her physical condition, etc. And, much of it included different conjectures
about how the murder and dismemberment took place and offered different
solutions as to who the murderer was. One seemed to make more sense to me than
most of the other conjectures, but even that example was cited by other writers
as including hypotheses along with facts. When I put it all together, I decided
to just see the film and see what happened and perhaps come to a conclusion of
my own.
That didn't work too well either since the story that film writer James Elroy
wrote was even more fanciful than some of the theories advanced by Black Dahlia
website writers. However, in one scene late in the picture, I noted an address
that attracted my attention: 6024 Carlos Ave. Carlos Ave. is a little three or
four block street that runs parallel to and one block north of Hollywood Blvd. I
had a girlfriend who lived on that street who, while I was in College, became
my steady for more than two years. Her address was 6062, which would have been
just a few houses further west.
6024 was owned by a man named Mark Hansen who also owned the Florentine Gardens
on Hollywood Blvd., which along with the Earl Carroll Theatre Restaurant was the
biggest nightclub operation in Hollywood at the time. Hansen also owned the near
by Martel theater which was a typical Los Angles neighborhood movie house. One
of my friends from advertising days was Frank Burke Jr., manager of radio
station KFVD in Los Angeles. Back during the war years Mr. Burke had been a
naval officer, stationed on Catalina Island off the Southern California coast.
He was very attracted to the lead singer at the Gardens, and regularly used to
go to the nightclub to sit around and wait for her to do her last vocal set. It
could be a long evening of waiting. Mr. Burke informed me many years ago that
the flamboyant MC at the Gardens, Nils Thor Granlund, popularly known as NTG,
would introduce the voluptuous young ladies doing their dance routines by
telling the customers to look at those big blue eyes.
Hansen was very generous in allowing use of his house. Some of his show girls
stayed there when necessary, one in particular of which, Ann Todd, was a friend
of Elizabeth Short, so that Short on a few occasions late in 1946 had also
stayed there.
I noticed one of the pictures of the Elizabeth Short that was on some of the
internet sites. There was something familiar about if. Here is that picture.
What caught my attention reminded me of the following picture which was taken in
August 1946.
It shows my army buddy Glen Stone and me on furlough before going overseas. It
was taken in front of the apartment of my girlfriend Valya Terry. What struck me
was the resemblance of the backgrounds in the two photos. Though, I was struck
by the resemblance I did note some slight differences. Further I had read in one
of the Elizabeth Short sites that she had some photos shot a few weeks before
her death at the nearby John Marshall High. After visiting the high school which
I attended 1941 - 1944, I could see the likelihood that the shots I thought were
in front of the Presbyterian Church were actually at various locations in front
of Marshall, though none of the photo's really were duplicated by similar
locations at Marshall. It was interesting that the passage of sixty years had no
effect on the traditional brick structure at the high school. My investigation
had proved interesting, but didn't result in the successful conclusion I had
initially advanced.
My second coincidence was related to Elinor Lynch a long time friend of my wife.
Ms. Lynch, then Elinor Schobach, moved to the neighborhood near the Black Dahlia
site after she graduated from the University of Illinois in 1949. Her parents
had moved out to L.A. the year before and had bought a house on Degnan Ave. near
Santa Barbara blvd. Their house was located just one and two blocks from where
Short's body was found. Degnan and Norton are two north/south streets that come
together just north of the Schobach house. Everyone in the neighborhood knew
about the murder that had occurred in 1947 and the discovery of the body on
Norton. Elinor explained that the area had been planned as a real estate
development before the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Sidewalks, curbs,
driveways, fire hydrants and the like were in, but because of the shortage of
building supplies nothing was built there. It was still empty lots when Elinor's
parents moved into their house. Elinor further noted that shortly after she
moved to L.A. the area was finally developed and was particularly popular with
Japanese-Americans who had been released from relocation centers a couple of
years earlier.
The third coincidence involves Betty Bersinger, the lady who discovered the
bi-sected and brutalized body of Elizabeth Short. In one of the articles about
the killing this lady's husband was identified as a John Bersinger. The name
struck me because I did know something about a John Bersinger who had been one
of the executives Mrs. Gardner had worked for in the 1970's and 80's. I had been
reading a history of the U.S. Eighth Air Force and their bombing missions over
Germany when I came across the name John Bersinger who had been the pilot of a
B-17 Flying Fortress shot down over the continent. I was interested in learning
more about his experiences which I discussed with him at a party at his house.
He noted being captured, escaping eventually and ending up flying more missions
later in the war. He particularly noted to me the importance to him of his first
crew, some of whom had been killed when their plane was shot down. He remembered
each individual personally. At that time I knew next to nothing about the Black
Dahlia case and so never brought the subject up. When I discovered the two
names, I asked Mrs. Gardner what John's wife's name was, and she told me she
thought it was Elizabeth. Well Betty and Elizabeth rang a bell. I did have the
e-mail address of Hal Althouse, another of Mrs. Gardner's bosses at the time,
and asked him if the Betty Bersinger identified by the press was John's wife.
Well in fact it was. John had told Mr. Althouse that he had been taken down to police
headquarters a couple of times and interrogated as a possible suspect.
It's a strange set of coincidences, but one I find very interesting. I suppose
there are other similar coincidences out there as well, but I just haven't run
into them as yet.
No comments:
Post a Comment